U4GM - POE 2: Does Currency Crafting Help or Hurt Build Diversity?
Path of Exile 2 (POE 2) is set to introduce a plethora of new mechanics, including an expanded and deeper crafting system, which has sparked much discussion in the community. One of the central elements of the game that players eagerly anticipate is the introduction of Poe 2 currency crafting, a feature that could drastically alter the way builds are developed and optimized. But the question remains: Does currency crafting help or hurt build diversity in POE 2?
Currency crafting is a feature that allows players to use different in-game currencies to modify, enhance, or re-roll item stats. This system, which was already a key part of Path of Exile 1, will see some significant changes and improvements in POE 2. The introduction of new crafting currencies will give players more ways to fine-tune their gear, but it also raises the question of whether this will lead to a more homogeneous meta or create exciting new opportunities for build diversity.
The Case for Currency Crafting Promoting Build Diversity
One of the main advantages of currency crafting is the potential for increased customization. In POE 1, crafting was already an essential tool for players to fine-tune their builds, and with the introduction of new currencies and mechanics in POE 2, this customization is set to expand further. Players will have more options to craft items that suit their specific needs, making it easier to experiment with different builds and strategies.
For example, the new crafting system may allow players to craft items that are better suited to niche or off-meta builds, which may have previously been difficult to optimize due to a lack of suitable gear. With the increased accessibility of crafting, players may be able to push the limits of their creativity and explore new ways to approach the game, resulting in a more diverse array of viable builds.
Furthermore, currency crafting could help balance the game's economy, as it would reduce the reliance on perfect, rare drops that players often need to complete their builds. This means players could focus on crafting their dream gear instead of waiting for the perfect item to drop from a boss or a league mechanic, potentially encouraging more build experimentation.
The Case for Currency Crafting Hindering Build Diversity
While currency crafting can open up many possibilities for customization, it also comes with certain risks. One concern is that the abundance of crafting currencies might lead to a more streamlined meta where players gravitate towards the same "best" item rolls. As more and more players perfect their builds using the same set of currencies, the game could see fewer unique or unconventional builds emerge.
In a similar vein, the extensive crafting system could inadvertently favor certain playstyles, such as high-damage builds, over others. The ease with which players can craft high-end gear might push the meta towards a narrower set of optimal builds, particularly if some crafting mods or affixes are disproportionately powerful. This could stifle creativity, as players might feel compelled to craft the "best" gear for a particular build, rather than trying something new and different.
Moreover, with more currencies being introduced, there is the potential for an overly complex crafting system, where players may need to engage in complex crafting strategies just to craft viable gear. This complexity could discourage newer players or those less interested in crafting from fully exploring the depth of the game, thus limiting the diversity of builds in the player base.
Striking a Balance: Can Currency Crafting Help Build Diversity?
Ultimately, whether currency crafting in POE 2 helps or hurts build diversity will depend on how the system is implemented and how the community adapts to it. If the game allows for a range of viable crafting options while still maintaining an element of risk and randomness, it could lead to a more diverse array of builds. However, if certain currencies or mods are too dominant, it might force players into a narrower meta that stifles creativity.
To strike a balance, it will be important for the developers to monitor the crafting economy closely and adjust crafting mechanics and currencies as needed. Ideally, currency crafting should provide players with the freedom to experiment and optimize their builds without making the game feel overly focused on a small subset of strategies.
Currency crafting in POE 2 certainly has the potential to both help and hurt build diversity. The system’s success will depend on its ability to encourage creativity without making certain builds or strategies overly dominant. If managed well, the crafting system can be a powerful tool for increasing build diversity, allowing players to experiment with a wider variety of playstyles. However, if not carefully balanced, it could lead to a more uniform meta that limits the variety of builds players can create. As with most systems in Path of Exile, the devil will be in the details—and the community will be watching closely.